Rated 4 out of 5 by 3
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lovemy2boys Nice set
The best part of this set is all three products are full size. It is hard to tell from the picture since the caps are off the liner, but it is full size as well. The red lipstick is beautiful and has a slight glimmer, so it is less matte than the average Color Design Lipstick. I only have two small complaints, neither of which are worth deducting any points.
The first is that the liner, Spiced Apple, is not well suited for the lipstick color. It does not match as well as Rougelle (a different liner I own) matches it. Spiced Apple seems more like an orange red whereas the lipstick seems like a blue red. I have cool undertones, so I doubt I will buy a lipstick to match the liner. Therefore, I am not sure at this point it will come in handy. The gloss and lipstick alone are worth more than the set cost, so it is not too big of a deal.
The second is that the liner does not lay flat in the bag. It only fits diagonally. I wish the bag was a little bigger. This is not too big of a deal as a liner will lay flat once it has been sharpened a few times.
Rated 5 out of 5 by erinC Beautiful Color Red
This is a vibrant red and I love it. It is my every day look now. I love Red Lips!
Rated 2 out of 5 by bahamamama This is NOT a true, Christmas red.
I bought this specifically for the lipstick and liner - but it turns out not to be a true red. In fact, I think it's a very odd tone that is very unflattering to me and that won't really go with anything I would wear except black or winter white. Very disappointed.